Автор: Ivan_A
Дата: 04-09-07 21:59
n1xOn,
Не правят и лоши обективи:
"The 9/2007 ColorFoto reviews 40 tele-zooms and comes up with some mighty surprising results, for some people.
To get to the quick:
Colorfoto tested Canon, Nikon, Pentax, Sony and Olympus OEM and add-on tele-zooms in two categories: fixed focal length and tele-zooms. For both tests the maximum points are 150.
Fixed Focal Length Zooms:
* Recommended for Digital
The worst 5 were the:
66.5 pts Canon EF/400 mm DO IS USM 6,700 €
*67 pts Pentax SMC-D-FA 2.8/100 Macro 550 €
*69.5 pts Sigma EX 2.8/300 DG APO HSM IF
(Canon Mount) 2,000 €
*71 pts Sigma EX 3.5/180 DG APO HSM IF
Macro (Canon Mount) 760 €
*71,5 pts Tamron AF 3,5/180 SP XR Di LD
(IF) 1:1 Macro (Canon Mount) 650 €
( the only other one not recommended for digital aside from the above mentioned Canon was the Nikkor 2.8/300 VR G IF-ED - 72.5 pts - 4,600 €)
The best 5 were the:
*92 pts Olympus ZD 2/150 ED 2,350 €
*86 pts Olympus ZD 2.8/300 ED 6,900 €
*80 pts Zeiss SAL Sonnar 1.8/135 ZA 1,400 €
*80 pts AF-S Nikkor 2/200 VR G IF-ED 4,000 €
*79.5 pts Sony SAL 2.8/100 Macro 840 € "
http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1022&message=24681211
"Top Five:
*83.0 pts Olympus ZD 2.8/90-250 ED 5.600 €
83.0 pts Olympus ZD 2.8-3.5/50-200 ED 970 €
*76.5 pts Sigma EX 4/100-300 DG APO HSM IF 1,180 €
(Nikon Mount)
*76.5 pts Nikkor AF-S 2.8/70-200 VR G IF-ED 1,850 €
*75.0 pts Nikkor AF-S 4,5-5,6/70-300 VR G IF-ED 520 €
Worst Five:
*66.0 pts Sigma EX 2.8/120-300 DG APO HSM IF 2,500 €
*66.0 pts Sigma EX 4.5-5.6/80-400 DG APO OS RF 1,200 €
*66.5 pts Tamron AF 4-5.6/70-300 DI LD Macro 130 €
*68.0 pts Canon EF 4.5-5.6/70-300 DO IS USM 1.060 €
*68.5 pts Nikkor AF-S 4/200-400 VR G IF-ED 5,900 € "
"The issue before was about wide angles where 7-14 got 85 points and 11-22 85.5. The closest wa zooms were only Sigma at 73 points and Tokina at 75.5 points. Nikon 12-24 got only 69 points and Nikon 14/2.8 prime got only 66.5 points."
Публикацията е редактирана (04-09-07 22:17)
|
|